1908 American Football Association Cup Final
The Milwaukee Brewmasters were the only one of the top four seeds to advance out of the first round.
The biggest upset was by the Green Bay Papermillers over the Boston Shipwrights. The Papermillers kept on winning after that, topping the Louisville Racehorses, the New York Fomorians, and the other Cinderella team of the tourney, the Richmond Railers.
The final had a derby atmosphere as the two Dairy State contestants squared off. In fact, some newspapers referred to it as the "Dairy Derby." The Blatz Platz was packed for the event. A special train ran from Green Bay to bring Papermiller fans to the game.
The match started slowly, but it was clear the Brewmasters were in control. Willi Franz opened the scoring for the Brewmasters, heading in a corner from Sean Hy. Irwin Day put another on the board after outrunning the Green Bay defense on a Pat O’Dea long pass. Green Bay pulled one back in the 49th minute when Willy Randolph wove his way through the Brewmaster back line. Milwaukee answered quickly two minutes later from a Richie Zerbel free kick. However, Irwin Day put the game out of reach with a powerful first-time volley off of a cleared ball in the 55th. Chris Page brought the Papermillers within two after a combination with Curtis Howe in the 62nd. After that, the Pat O’Dea defense shut the Papermillers down, and the Brewmasters claimed their second AFA Cup.
In doing so, the Milwaukee Brewmasters completed a double, the first time since the 1901 Baltimore Chimney Swifts, in winning both the Ultimate Division and American Football Association Cup.