The Baltimore Bannerets no longer can simply be called “the other team in Baltimore.” In the 1908-1909 season, they achieved the same level of success that the Baltimore Chimney Swifts had on 3 previous occasions – AAAFL Ultimate Division champions. The Bannerets jockeyed for first position over the fall portion of the season with the Privateers and defending champion Brewmasters. They climbed to the top during Week 13 and remained there for the spring season. While the Brewmasters faded, the Chimney Swifts moved up to challenge the Bannerets, but the younger club kept a healthy lead in the table, finishing 3 points ahead.
The newly promoted Cincinnati Scarlets had a decent season, finishing in the middle of the table. The other promoted squad, the Washington Insiders, managed to finish 2 points ahead of relegation. The bottom of the table saw the Detroit Longtails and Brooklyn Bridegrooms (again) finish in the relegation zone.
Two members of the Bannerets made the Top 11 Squad – Forward Gavin Fitzgerald and Goalkeeper Jack Dennis. The Boston Shipwrights placed five, despite their 5th place finish. One of them, Vance French, tallied the most points for the year and also won the Golden Ball.