Offline

Hey yall! I’m just going to make a little thread here documenting what I find interesting about stuff. I could make a private notes page but I figure it might have some use to a community that focuses on the alternative history of sport.
1877: the Americans in intersquad scrimmages were extremely lopsided. The forwards on the varsity teams were big, while the “scrub” teams couldn’t maintain possession during a breakdown (scrum formed after the tackle). The scrubs began allowing balls to be kicked past them in the forward pile (I’m unsure of how this worked or what the rules were, it seems as though players weren’t allowed to take the ball out of the scrum and relied on kicking it to a player out of the scrum) and into the waiting hands of their halfbacks, who could gain yards by evading the mass. Eventually, they began kicking it back to themselves. This would evolve into the “snapback”, which would further evolve into the snap at the line of scrimmage.
1878-1879: centers and guards are established to protect the ball from becoming the opponent’s, with guards protecting the flanks and the center “middle rusher” snapping the ball.
1880: Americans evolve the game to contain an uncontested scrum, because they are bad the scrum. The quarterback is first defined as the player to take the ball from the snap.
1880-1881: the uncontested scrum presents an issue. Teams can just hold onto the ball forever. This becomes known as “the block game.” In addition, if a team goes too far backward, they can run the ball back into their own goal for a “safety touchdown”. This awards zero points.
Spring 1882: an emergency summit is called. Instead of allowing for a contested scrum and defining the rules of a breakdown (as what occurs in Rugby Union), they decide to adopt Walter Camp’s down and distance rule over Princeton’s four consecutive downs rule. It is decided: 3 plays for 5 yards. This is radical.
Late 1882: points are decided in relation to safety touchdowns.
Safety
1
Touchdown
2
Goal following touchdown
4
Goal from field
5
Offline

1880: Yale had been pushing for this forever and finally gets 11-per side instead of Rugby’s 15. It also gets a line of scrimmage alongside the uncontested scrum.
Offline

I think the biggest thing I'm going to keep from American football rules (which becomes a big thing near the try line) is the removal of a "maul-in-goal" in 1885. Teams would effectively hold up players from touching the ball down for minutes at a time (because they didn't have a "use it" rule and I guess players didn't/couldn't pass the ball back in a maul), and so the Americans decided to make it so that a ball that crossed the plane rewarded a try.
Offline

Wikipedia tells me that the rouge existed as a rule in early association football, as well as a bunch of english juvenile games. I think a single would be a good way to increase offensive output when coupled with a breaking the plane rule, with teams trying to hang more kicks in the back corner and only being penalized if the ball goes into touch in-goal. You'd still get American-style toe taps and the riskier dives to the try line, generating better scoring opportunities inside the 25.