Alternate History Sports

You are not logged in. Would you like to login or register?

7/13/2026 9:34 pm  #1


National Ice Hockey Association

Hello everyone, I'm back. It's been a while; a lot of things have been a roller coaster outside of this AHS world. I'll leave it at that. As for my other league (CIHA), it's on hiatus for the time being until the blue moon shines over my head to get back at it; now I have been working on this for almost a year, a pro hockey league and here we are as I present to you the National Ice Hockey Association.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------


History of the NIHA
Pre-NIHA era, 1890-1925
Many people claim that ice hockey originated in Canada, while others argue it originated elsewhere. In 1880’s a group of collage students from the university of Toronto created a amateur hockey league after the sport became popular called the Toronto Hockey League (THL) which it grew from 6 teams to 18 teams by 1890, however there is a caveat with the success, in 1893, 6 teams in the Toronto area folded out of nowhere, many other try to claim players to build their own as powerhouse club, which lead to problems along the way with players being paid too much for not showing up to even a team played one game, then folded the next day so Paul Benjaman rose up to became the first lone president of the THL and decide to put a maximum pay rule on the owners of club that pay players way too much by disqualify them from playing in the playoffs. After adding more rules to the league, many other owners sought ways to generate revenue, leading them to relocate teams from the Toronto area to other parts of Ontario. One team from Mississauga was the first to move. They moved to Waterloo, Ontario and renamed themselves from the Mississauga Hockey Club to the Waterloo Engineers. As more teams left the Toronto area, the six remaining teams realized they wouldn’t survive. In 1895, they merged to form the Toronto Professional Hockey Club, later shortened to the Toronto Pros. And since then, the THL has kept it together as the new century arrived.

Meanwhile, along the maritime coast, several teams were formed, and in 1898, a new league, the Maritime Hockey Association (MHA), was established. A gentleman named William Alexander, who loved the game so much that he bought a trophy and presented it to the winner of the MHA, and the trophy is named the Alexander Cup. As the 1900s came around many teams were having a great times until in 1904 where the Truro Hawks a all-black hockey club forced to fold after their rink got turned into a railroad where many called that event the “white line” since then the MHA struggled to keep it afloat by 1907 the league ceased operation and the Quebec Professional Hockey Association (QPHA) was born featuring Fredericton Diamonds, Halifax Cyclones, Cape Breton Indians, and PEI Whales that was part of MHA, a long with some teams from Quebec, some used to be part of MHA but folded during the last part of the downfall most of the Quebec teams are new, the Montreal Or Rouge, Quebec City Owls, Drummondville Cardinals, Trois-Rivieres Mallards, Rimouski Otters, and Chicoutimi Redwoods. With the Alexander Cup in tow, the QPHA ran well throughout the 1900s and the 1910s.

After a visit in Ontario and saw some hockey games many businessmen took the idea and brought them to America and in the year 1910 the American Coast Hockey League started with the Pittsburgh, Philadelphia, Cleveland, Buffalo, Erie, and Baltimore as years come by they would add more along with the New York Mad Hatters in 1915, in their second year into the ACHL they won their first championship as forth seed team and would win four more championships along the way until the 1920s where many teams couldn’t make ends meet at all to a point that the Mad Hatters have to look for a new league to be part of it in order to keep everything a float.

One day in 1924 Paul Benjaman decide to meet with Jonathon Laflamme the current president of the QPHA and Ben Millen the president of the ACHL in talks about a merger within the three leagues together as one in hope to get out of a bad debt that could put ice hockey to cease to exist, both Jonathon and Ben were not too fond of the idea but comes two businessmen Franklin Stanley and Rick Kitchen came in to part of the idea with one condition that they put their own teams as part of the new league, one in Chicago and one in Minnesota, with that both Jonathon and Ben took Paul’s offer. With that, they slowly picked out many teams that could be part of it. In 1924, they had 10 teams ready to go, but by 1925, half had folded, leaving only 5. The creation is sadly complete, with only five teams: the Toronto Pros, Montreal Or Rouge, New York Mad Hatters, Minnesota Nationals, and Chicago Lynx, as part of the league called the National Ice Hockey Association. The Alexander Cup will be the league’s ultimate prize. Many hope this league will not experience as many growing pains as the other three leagues.

Next post: The Founding Five Teams

 

7/14/2026 8:37 pm  #2


Re: National Ice Hockey Association

Always fun to see a new project! Looking forward to this!



AHS Admin. Creator of the THLPUCHWHA: Redux and Retroliga.
 

7/15/2026 6:19 pm  #3


Re: National Ice Hockey Association

The Founding Five Teams


Gold and navy are the team’s colours, and the name Lynx comes from a type of bobcat that owner Rick Kitchen had to name it due to originally being called the Lancers, but a pro football team is using it and won’t let Rick use it. The jersey is gold with four navy stripes on the arms, hem, and socks; the four stripes represent the club as the fourth sport played in Chicago (right behind baseball, football, and basketball), and the interlocking letters C and L form the team’s main crest.


Named after many established national parks in the state, including two mountain hills in green and white as the crest, the jersey is green with a white yoke, cuffs, a single stripe on the hem and on the sock.


Gold English-style letter M as the main crest in a red jersey with a stripe on the arms, hem, sock and yoke in gold. The name is a French word for Red Golds.


Red is the team’s main colour, along with blue; the jersey design is the same as the one they wore from their beginnings in 1915, with a red yoke. The crest is red NY with blue trim around it.


Blue and grey have been their main colours since 1895, with the stripes within the crest representing the six founders of the team, who merged their teams into one. Two grey stripes on the arms, hem, and socks on the whole blue jersey.

Next Post: 1925-26 NIHA Season

     Thread Starter
 

7/18/2026 9:08 pm  #4


Re: National Ice Hockey Association


It took a while to get the league going, but on November 20, 1925, the first game of the NIHA inaugural season was played as the president of NIHA, Paul Benjamin, watched the Toronto Pros beat the New York Mad Hatters 4-2. The Pros' top scorer, Maple Thomas, led the team with his first hat trick of the season. The next night, spectators witnessed a very competitive game between the Chicago Lancers and the Minnesota Nationals, which ended in a 5-5 tie. The Montreal Or Rouge was the top team in the league, thanks to John Giroux, Marc Dupont, and Etienne Rehnquist, who formed the league's most dominant line. Behind them were the Toronto Pros in second place, followed by the Minnesota Nationals in third, the Chicago Lynx in fourth, and the New York Mad Hatters in last place.

The playoff format features the top 4 teams, with the last-place team eliminated. The semi-final and final are both best-of-5-game series. In the semi-final, the OR Rouge wastes no time and beats the Lynx in three games, while the Nationals shock the league and end the Pros' season, and it took all five games to do it.
The battle between the Montreal Or Rouge and the Minnesota Nationals for the Alexander Cup. The Nationals played well, but it was not enough, as Or Rouge star Etienne Rehnquist scored six of the nine goals to go on and win it in three games, becoming the first Alexander Cup champions in NIHA history.


Next Post: 1926-27 Season

     Thread Starter
 

7/20/2026 7:38 pm  #5


Re: National Ice Hockey Association


After last year's disappointment, the Mad Hatters made some big changes to the roster; most of the core veterans were replaced with fresh new players like Joe “Rat” Robinson, who didn’t make the cut last year. This year, he topped the league with 35 goals and 56 points, helping the team go from worst to first.  The Nationals improved from third place last year to second this year, thanks in part to Harold Orton, who has been a brick wall for the team since last season. The defending Alex Cup champions, Montreal, had lost several key players to retirement, including Jean Ranou, who was part of the team in its pre-NIHA days. With some new players added, the team would finish third. Toronto’s Maple Thomas had a rough season, being the only player on the team to play a full 32 games; some players barely made it past 16 games, but Maple's contributions helped the Pros finish fourth. Even though the Lynx made it to the playoffs last year, they couldn’t keep the roster intact due to players not being paid, which led to their top player, Trevor Bell, who was on a roll in scoring, choosing not to put more effort in for the rest of the season until he and other teammates got paid, but later discovered that owner Rick Kitchen is losing money in a bad way and he can’t up the ticket price just to keep the team afloat, in the end the Chicago Lancers finish last place.

Playoffs
Semi-Finals
Both semi-finals went all the way to five games each. In one semi, the Mad Hatters believed they would take the Pros out, but the Pros gave them a hard time. In game five, Rat Robinson led the team with three goals to win 5-2 over the Pros to advance to the Alexander Cup Championship. The rematch from last year's Alexander Cup Championship and the Nationals made huge wins to lead the series 2-0, but Montreal bounced back and became the first team in history to come back from trailing 2-0 to win the series 3-2, all thanks to Marc Dupont, who didn’t play well this season but stepped up in the playoffs.

Alexander Cup Championship
The New York Mad Hatters may be the top team in the league, but their young roster was no match for the Montreal Or Rouge, Montreal would win the first two games in New York until in game three were the Mad Hatters won it in Montreal but in game four the Mad Hatters ran out of fuel as the Or Rouge filled with veterans was scoring from all angles for a 6-1 score to win the Alexander Cup Championship for the second year in a row, the last team to ever win the Cup back-to-back was the Rimouski Otters (1920-1921) before the NIHA was established.

Next Post: 1927-28 Season

Last edited by AJHFTW (7/24/2026 8:49 pm)

     Thread Starter
 

7/25/2026 5:59 pm  #6


Re: National Ice Hockey Association


During the off-season, the Chicago Lynx acquired a new owner, Edward Elsbridge, a businessman from the west side of Chicago. After several failed attempts to purchase a professional baseball team, Edward was given the opportunity to buy the Lynx hockey team, and he took it, hoping to turn the team around. Many owners are planning an expansion, adding five more teams as it was supposed to have before the league’s inaugural season, but the NIHA president, Paul Benjaman, shot it down because he didn’t want to go through the same issues as the last time, and he said, “As long as I’m the NIHA president, we are not going to expand big number of teams and that’s that!”
The Minnesota Nationals finished first in the standings the hard way, experiencing some good winning streaks, but also endured a rough eight-game losing streak in the last ten games of the season, led by their top player, Victor Tillman, who had been playing amateur leagues for years until he got on the Nats roster and became the first player in NIHA history to reach 100 points (32 goals, 68 assists) one of big success that any player could pull off. The Toronto Pros had the opportunity to take first place, but that plan backfired after losing the last four games to both New York and Chicago. For the second year in a row, the Montreal Or Rouge finished in third place, losing players from the 1910s to retirements, which means a rebuild is on the way. From first to fourth, the New York Mad Hatters lost a significant portion of their roster as they fought for the last playoff spot, particularly in the last game of the season, where they defeated Chicago 3-1 to secure fourth place. Even though they had youth on the roster, it didn’t help the Lynx get themselves out of the bottom of the barrel. However, they scored 21 points, four more than last season.

1928 Playoffs
The Minnesota Nationals took out the Mad Hatters in three games without issues, with Nats' rookie Victor Tillman leading the way with 10 goals within those three games. It was a back-and-forth series between the Pros and the Or Rouge all the way to game five, where both were tied 4-4 after the third period. Five minutes left in overtime; Maple Thomas scored the game-winner for a series win and a trip to the Alexander Cup Championship for the Toronto Pros.

Alexander Cup Championship
The Minnesota Nationals made no mistakes; they made the right plays and shut down the Pros' offence in many ways. And so, as game three came to an end, the Nationals celebrated as they became the first American pro hockey team to win the Alexander Cup in the trophy's existence. Victor Tillman had one of the best seasons in his hockey career. Sadly, one month after winning the Cup, Victor got into a car accident that paralyzed him and ended his career.

Next Post: 1928-29 Season

Last edited by AJHFTW (7/25/2026 6:01 pm)

     Thread Starter
 

Board footera