Coming into the 1923/24 season there were 2 more teams set to join. Rather than join the Iron Range league, they convinced the Duluth Hornets and Cloquet Broncos to leave and create their own league as Duluth and Cloquet had a long trip for most away games. Thus the Lake Superior Hockey League was born, with the Cloquet Broncos, Duluth Hornets, Duluth Voyageurs, and Superior Lakers being the founding teams.
The Duluth Voyageurs are named after the french fur traders that set up a trading post in the city and helped make it the port city it has become. Their colors are blue, red and white; the colors of the french flag, and their logo is a fleur de lis. The Voyageurs are often referred to by locals as "le bleus" due to the color of their uniforms as well as the french history of the area.

The Superior Lakers name is pretty straight forward, their colors are blue and white with black accents. The blue is supposed to represent Lake Superior. The Lakers are the first team in the Minnesota Amateur Hockey League to be from another state, being from Wisconsin.