Alternate History Sports / AltLB Design Thread

**Posted by Darknes** 8/14/2021 7:37 pm

sportsfan7 wrote:
Burmy87 wrote:
2. I like how the name Masons works as well for Boston's stonemason history...whether or not designers will want to include Freemasonry aspects in it is up to them (Keep in mind, Boston also has a heavy Catholic heritage, where membership in Freemasonry is strictly forbidden)
Yeah, this was why I kept voting against Masons. The name is good in a vacuum, but problematic in such a heavily Catholic city like Boston

Yet the Freemasons' Grand Lodge in Mass, is the Oldest in the US and 3rd Oldest behind only the Lodges in the UK and Ireland.

And the Freemasons themselves had no Ban on Catholics joining them, and the earlier era of Boston anyways would have been more Protestant than Catholic

Last edited by Darknes (8/14/2021 7:46 pm)

**Posted by Megildur** 8/14/2021 10:39 pm

Gritty wrote:
The Deacons beat our the Robins (which was the more popular of the two in round 1) in the finals

Noooo, say it ain't so! I was rather proud of my Robins idea, but I ranked Deacons highly as well IIRC.

Still, I love this first group of names. So, here are some initial design ideas if anyone's interested:
- The Keystones and Blackbirds stand out the strongest to me. I could see the Keystones looking something like my Philly concept here. Meanwhile, I think some combination of the White Sox, Pirates, and a cool bird logo could make New York pop. Plus, as Burmy mentioned too, NYC has a black and yellow theme going.
- The Pros remind me of the Mets, so I was thinking a skyline logo could be cool or a speakeasy styled Brewers' Barrelman type thing.
- Detroit could have the Swingin' Deacon, who wields a crozier like a bat?
- And then for Boston, an old English styled B would work wonders.

Here's to hoping I'll get more than one name into the final fours this round, though may the best win. I'm impressed by all the ideas out there (and saving ideas for my own fictional OOTP play too)

**Posted by sportsfan7** 8/15/2021 12:48 am

Darknes wrote:
sportsfan7 wrote:
Burmy87 wrote:
2. I like how the name Masons works as well for Boston's stonemason history...whether or not designers will want to include Freemasonry aspects in it is up to them (Keep in mind, Boston also has a heavy Catholic heritage, where membership in Freemasonry is strictly forbidden)
Yeah, this was why I kept voting against Masons. The name is good in a vacuum, but problematic in such a heavily Catholic city like Boston
Yet the Freemasons' Grand Lodge in Mass, is the Oldest in the US and 3rd Oldest behind only the Lodges in the UK and Ireland.

And the Freemasons themselves had no Ban on Catholics joining them, and the earlier era of Boston anyways would have been more Protestant than Catholic

Yes, but, generally speaking, Catholics have a negative view of the Freemasons and other similar groups, so Freemason-inspired club in a heavily Catholic city is probably a bad idea.

**Posted by QCS** 8/15/2021 10:02 am

Not super feeling Deacons for Detroit because we did the religious theme for the Angels, but I think we'll get some separation in terms of colors and general direction. Super glad that both Keystones and Pros won, I think we'll get some awesome, classic sets for those teams. Blackbirds is cool, Masons is meh to me, but overall a strong start. Looking forward to the rest!

**Posted by Dan O'Mac** 8/15/2021 10:48 am

QCS wrote:
Not super feeling Deacons for Detroit because we did the religious theme for the Angels, but I think we'll get some separation in terms of colors and general direction. Super glad that both Keystones and Pros won, I think we'll get some awesome, classic sets for those teams. Blackbirds is cool, Masons is meh to me, but overall a strong start. Looking forward to the rest!

We did Angels for Detroit... then gave them a good ornament logo, making them back to automotive in my mind.

**Posted by QCS** 8/15/2021 11:07 am

Dan O'Mac wrote:
QCS wrote:
Not super feeling Deacons for Detroit because we did the religious theme for the Angels, but I think we'll get some separation in terms of colors and general direction. Super glad that both Keystones and Pros won, I think we'll get some awesome, classic sets for those teams. Blackbirds is cool, Masons is meh to me, but overall a strong start. Looking forward to the rest!

We did Angels for Detroit... then gave them a good ornament logo, making them back to automotive in my mind.

Fair enough, I suppose. I guess I don't really like the way "Deacons" sounds. Personal preference.

**Posted by Gritty** **Online!** 8/15/2021 4:32 pm

The Finals!
https://forms.gle/rLveAxvoWvdBkCQz7

Group 3 Nominations
https://forms.gle/vxuDBjFPrHQvVkf66

**Posted by Thehealthiestscratch** 8/15/2021 5:14 pm

Heads up, KC also has the Marshals.

**Posted by BDoof** 8/15/2021 9:17 pm

0-5 again, smh. Though some of these nominations are pretty good

**Posted by Gritty** **Online!** 8/16/2021 10:15 pm

We have some crazy close races for Group B. So close that we need two sudden death runoffs. Enjoy!

https://forms.gle/Dz9ZfGxeAptutpmc7